Higher Tariffs Put India's Economy at Risk, Says Former Advisor
Former Chief Economic Advisor Arvind Subramanian stated in an interview that India's economy is not exhibiting signs of a strong rebound and that the prospects could be weakened by the possibility of increasing dumping of cheap Chinese goods and higher US tariffs.
India's GDP expanded 7.4% in the year ended in March, according to data released this week as part of the government's advance projections, continuing the country's record-breaking growth streak.
In an interview with Menaka Doshi of Bloomberg Television on Friday, Subramanian stated, "We should read that figure cautiously." Given an exceptionally low deflator, which is used to exclude inflation from the gross domestic product calculation, he said the estimate may suffer from the "age-old problem" of whether it is correctly measured.
“Even directionally, it is not obvious that the economy is recovering,” said Subramanian, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics. He pointed to decelerating nominal indicators and slowing high-frequency data as reasons for caution about both the level and direction of growth.
“I would not put a precise number on growth, but if growth next year ends up similar to this year, India should consider itself fortunate and view that as a job well done, given the heightened uncertainty,” he said.
Risks from US trade policy also remain high. President Donald Trump’s punitive 50% tariffs on Indian goods, partly linked to New Delhi’s purchases of Russian oil, added to the uncertainty. “It is now looking less likely that there will be a trade deal,” Subramanian said, adding that “tariff rates may even move higher.”
India also faces pressure from what Subramanian described as “Chinese mercantilism,” as it rapidly exports and diverts goods to developing countries, including India, weighing on the domestic economy.
He also flagged concerns around public finances. “While the macro position is reasonably strong, the fiscal situation, partly because of Goods and Services Tax cuts, is not as strong as it should be,” he said.
Subramanian sought greater flexibility in currency policy, arguing that exporters need support amid external shocks. With limited fiscal space, he said, currency depreciation may be the only effective channel. “However, the Reserve Bank of India appears reluctant to allow the rupee to be fully flexible. That policy stance needs closer examination,” he said.
The rupee has depreciated about 5% over the past year and slid past 91 to the dollar in December, as RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra showed greater willingness than his predecessor, Shaktikanta Das, to let the currency align more closely with market forces. Still, the RBI’s “intervention in currency markets remains well above what is needed to smooth volatility,” Subramanian said.
India's GDP expanded 7.4% in the year ended in March, according to data released this week as part of the government's advance projections, continuing the country's record-breaking growth streak.
In an interview with Menaka Doshi of Bloomberg Television on Friday, Subramanian stated, "We should read that figure cautiously." Given an exceptionally low deflator, which is used to exclude inflation from the gross domestic product calculation, he said the estimate may suffer from the "age-old problem" of whether it is correctly measured.
“Even directionally, it is not obvious that the economy is recovering,” said Subramanian, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics. He pointed to decelerating nominal indicators and slowing high-frequency data as reasons for caution about both the level and direction of growth.
“I would not put a precise number on growth, but if growth next year ends up similar to this year, India should consider itself fortunate and view that as a job well done, given the heightened uncertainty,” he said.
Risks from US trade policy also remain high. President Donald Trump’s punitive 50% tariffs on Indian goods, partly linked to New Delhi’s purchases of Russian oil, added to the uncertainty. “It is now looking less likely that there will be a trade deal,” Subramanian said, adding that “tariff rates may even move higher.”
India also faces pressure from what Subramanian described as “Chinese mercantilism,” as it rapidly exports and diverts goods to developing countries, including India, weighing on the domestic economy.
He also flagged concerns around public finances. “While the macro position is reasonably strong, the fiscal situation, partly because of Goods and Services Tax cuts, is not as strong as it should be,” he said.
Subramanian sought greater flexibility in currency policy, arguing that exporters need support amid external shocks. With limited fiscal space, he said, currency depreciation may be the only effective channel. “However, the Reserve Bank of India appears reluctant to allow the rupee to be fully flexible. That policy stance needs closer examination,” he said.
The rupee has depreciated about 5% over the past year and slid past 91 to the dollar in December, as RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra showed greater willingness than his predecessor, Shaktikanta Das, to let the currency align more closely with market forces. Still, the RBI’s “intervention in currency markets remains well above what is needed to smooth volatility,” Subramanian said.
Comments
Post a Comment